The recent election of Robert Prevost as the new pope—now Pope Leo XIV—shocked the world with its historic significance. As the first American to ascend to the papacy, his appointment on May 8 marks a turning point for the Catholic Church. Yet while many were caught off guard, those closest to him say he may have seen it coming.
In the hours before the secretive conclave began, Robert Prevost spoke with his older brother John in what seemed like a casual conversation. But the tone suggested more than idle speculation. As the two brothers chatted, Pope Leo hinted—perhaps subtly, perhaps confidently—that he might be chosen.
John Prevost, a retired Catholic school principal from New Lenox, Illinois, recalled the surreal moment when the announcement was made. “I was just sitting there, phone in one hand, watching the coverage on TV like everyone else,” John said. “Then suddenly, my phone and iPad started lighting up like fireworks. Messages kept pouring in. That’s when I knew it wasn’t a dream.”
Though he was in disbelief, John had reason to suspect something big was coming. “When we spoke before the conclave, there was something in his voice,” he said. “He wasn’t boasting or predicting the future, but you could sense a quiet confidence. I think deep down he had a feeling.”
Robert Prevost, now Pope Leo XIV, had long been considered a strong spiritual leader and respected figure within the Church, but few expected the College of Cardinals to break tradition by choosing an American. The papacy has historically favored Europeans, with a significant number hailing from Italy. Pope Leo XIV’s selection represents a departure not only in nationality but perhaps in tone and direction as well.
John described his brother as humble and deeply committed to faith and service. “He never sought out power or prestige,” he said. “He’s always followed where he believes God calls him, and I think that’s what brought him here.”
Interestingly, Pope Leo XIV had been advised by some to remain low-profile before the conclave. Speculation and media attention can often work against a candidate in the eyes of the Cardinals. But according to sources close to him, he brushed aside some of that advice, choosing instead to be authentic and spiritually open.
“That’s just who he is,” John said. “He doesn’t play games or put on a show. He prays, he listens, and he acts when called.”
While the world continues to digest the monumental nature of his appointment, those who know Pope Leo XIV best believe he’s exactly where he’s meant to be. His brother still seems overwhelmed by the magnitude of it all. “It hasn’t sunk in yet,” John admitted. “I look at the news and think, ‘That’s my little brother.’ But I also know the Church is in good hands.”
